December 4, 2023

By JOSEPH KRAUSS | Related Press

JERUSALEM — Within the three and a half a long time because it started as an underground militant group, Hamas has pursued a constantly violent technique aimed toward rolling again Israeli rule — and it has made regular progress regardless of bringing monumental struggling to either side of the battle.

However its beautiful incursion into Israel over the weekend marks its deadliest gambit but, and the already unprecedented response from Israel threatens to convey an finish to its 16-year rule over the Gaza Strip.

Israel’s retaliation for the Hamas assault, wherein over 1,200 individuals had been killed in Israel and dozens dragged into Gaza as hostages, will doubtless convey a far higher magnitude of dying and destruction to Gaza, the place 2.3 million Palestinians have nowhere to flee and the place 1,100 have already been killed.

Hamas officers say they’re ready for any situation, together with a drawn-out conflict, and that allies like Iran and Lebanon’s Hezbollah will be a part of the battle if Israel goes too far.

“I don’t assume anybody actually is aware of what the endgame is in the meanwhile,” stated Tahani Mustafa, a Palestinian analyst on the Disaster Group, a world assume tank. However given the quantity of planning concerned within the assault, “it’s troublesome to think about they haven’t tried to strategize each potential situation.”

Shaul Shay, an Israeli researcher and retired colonel who served in navy intelligence, stated Hamas “miscalculated” Israel’s response and now faces a far worse battle than it had anticipated.

“I hope and I consider that Israel won’t cease till Hamas has been defeated within the Gaza Strip, and I don’t assume that this was their expectation earlier than the operation,” Shay stated of Hamas.


From its institution within the late Nineteen Eighties, on the eve of the primary Palestinian intifada, or rebellion, Hamas has been dedicated to armed battle and the destruction of Israel. On the top of the peace course of within the Nineteen Nineties, it launched scores of suicide bombings and different assaults that killed a whole lot of Israeli civilians. The violence solely intensified with the breakdown in peace talks and the far deadlier second Palestinian rebellion in 2000.

Hamas assaults had been met with huge Israeli navy incursions into the occupied West Financial institution and Gaza that exacted a far heavier dying toll on Palestinians. However because the violence wound down in 2005, Israel unilaterally withdrew its troopers and a few 8,000 Jewish settlers from Gaza, whereas sustaining tight management over entry to the enclave by land, air and sea.

Hamas claimed the withdrawal as vindication for its method, and the next 12 months it gained a landslide victory in Palestinian elections. In 2007, after bitter infighting, it violently seized Gaza from the internationally acknowledged Palestinian Authority.

Over the subsequent 16 years, via 4 wars and numerous smaller battles with Israel that rained devastation upon Gaza, Hamas solely grew extra highly effective. Every time it had extra rockets that traveled farther. Every time its high leaders survived, securing a cease-fire and the gradual easing of a blockade imposed by Israel and Egypt. Within the meantime, it constructed a authorities — together with a police drive, ministries and border terminals with metallic detectors and passport management.

And what of the 1000’s of Palestinians killed, the flattened condominium blocks, the crumbling infrastructure, the suffocating journey restrictions, the numerous desires deferred in Gaza, a 40-kilometer (25-mile) coastal strip sandwiched between Israel and Egypt?

Hamas blamed Israel, as did many Palestinians. The Hamas authorities has seen solely sporadic protests through the years and has rapidly and violently suppressed them.


If Hamas’ armed battle in opposition to Israel appears like a failure — or a lot worse — think about the choice.

The Palestinian management within the West Financial institution acknowledged Israel and renounced armed battle over three a long time in the past, hoping it might result in a state within the West Financial institution, Gaza and east Jerusalem, territories seized by Israel within the 1967 Mideast conflict.

However the talks repeatedly broke down, partly due to Hamas’ violence but in addition due to Israel’s relentless growth of settlements, now house to greater than a half million Israelis. There have been no critical peace talks in properly over a decade, and the Palestinian Authority has develop into little greater than an administrative physique within the 40% of the occupied West Financial institution the place it’s allowed to function.

Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas, an 87-year-old reasonable, has been powerless to cease settlement growth, settler violence, house demolitions or the unraveling of longstanding preparations round a delicate Jerusalem holy website. He has been sidelined throughout each Gaza conflict — together with this one — and the Palestinian Authority is broadly seen as a corrupt confederate to the occupation.

“Palestinians have tried all the things from elections to boycotts to the (Worldwide Prison Court docket) to partaking in a supposed peace course of,” stated Mustafa, of the Disaster Group. “You’ve had one of the conciliatory leaderships in all the historical past of the Palestinian nationwide motion, and that also hasn’t been sufficient.”

Nonetheless, the dimensions of final weekend’s assault takes Hamas’ method into uncharted territory.

“It’s unclear what Hamas’ endgame is past both preventing to the dying or liberating Palestine,” stated Hugh Lovatt, a Mideast knowledgeable on the European Council on Overseas Relations.

The newest assault marks a “full strategic rupture,” he stated.

“Regardless of conducting assaults in opposition to civilians previously and preventing earlier wars in opposition to Israel, (Hamas) did additionally concurrently have interaction in political tracks,” together with negotiations with Abbas’ Fatah motion and even tacit coordination with Israel, Lovatt stated.

“Now it seems to have totally embraced open-ended violence as its long-term strategic alternative.”


Israel seems more and more prone to launch a floor offensive in Gaza. It may reoccupy the territory and attempt to uproot Hamas, in what would absolutely be an extended and bloody counterinsurgency. However even that may simply drive the group — which can also be current in Lebanon and the West Financial institution — again underground.

And Hamas has a horrifying trump card that might give Israel pause.

Hamas and the extra radical Islamic Jihad militant group are holding some 150 males, girls and kids who had been captured and dragged into Gaza. Hamas’ armed wing claims some have already been killed in Israeli strikes and has threatened to kill captives if Israel assaults Palestinian civilians with out warning.